Home » Culture » Stanley Kubrick & Arthur C. Clarke Spent Years Debating Find out how to Depict the Aliens in 2001: A Area Odyssey; Carl Sagan Offered the Reply: Do not Depict Them at All

Stanley Kubrick & Arthur C. Clarke Spent Years Debating Find out how to Depict the Aliens in 2001: A Area Odyssey; Carl Sagan Offered the Reply: Do not Depict Them at All


The statute of limitations has certainly expired for Contact, the 1997 Robert Zemeckis adaptation of Carl Sagan’s eponymous novel. The movie suggests early on that Earth has been receiving communications from outer area, however for many of its two and a half hours retains its viewers in suspense as to the character of the extraterrestrials sending them. When Jodie Foster’s astronomer protagonist lastly will get some one-on-one time with an alien, it takes the type of her personal long-dead father, who impressed her selection of profession. This ending rapidly grew to become fodder for South Park jokes, however time appears to have vindicated it; any look again on the CGI aliens in different motion pictures of the mid-nineteen-nineties confirms that the appropriate selection was made.

Contact was not a simple book-to-film adaptation. Somewhat, Sagan and his spouse Ann Druyan supposed the venture as a movie first, and even wrote an in depth script therapy earlier than publishing the story as a novel. About three many years earlier, 2001: A Area Odyssey had emerged out of a equally unconventional course of. Somewhat than adapting an current ebook, as he’d achieved earlier than with Lolita and Dr. Strangelove, Stanley Kubrick and Arthur C. Clarke determined to work collectively on the concepts that might form each a movie directed by the previous and a novel written by the latter. The collaboration had its difficulties, not least when it got here time to deliver their imaginative and prescient of mankind’s future to a satisfying shut.

Enter Sagan, already on his solution to turning into a widely known thinker concerning the universe and man’s place inside it. “My good friend Arthur C. Clarke had an issue,” he remembers in his ebook The Cosmic Connection. “He was writing a serious movement image with Stanley Kubrick” (then referred to as Journey Past the Stars) on which “a small disaster within the story growth had arisen.” Within the movie a spacecraft’s crew “was to make contact with extraterrestrials. Sure, however tips on how to painting the extraterrestrials?” Kubrick had concepts about going the standard route, creating aliens “not profoundly completely different from human beings” and thus portrayable by people in fits, very similar to the apes on the monolith

Sagan opposed this, as “the variety of individually unlikely occasions within the evolutionary historical past of Man was so nice that nothing like us is ever prone to evolve once more anyplace else within the universe. I recommended that any specific illustration of a sophisticated extraterrestrial being was sure to have at the least a component of falseness about it, and that the most effective answer could be to counsel, moderately than explicitly to show, the extraterrestrials.” Kubrick in the end did select that creative path, leading to such haunting, alien-free scenes because the ending whereby David Bowman encounters his aged self in an eighteenth-century bed room. Whether or not or not that was fairly what he had in thoughts, Sagan did credit score Kubrick’s 2001 with “increasing the common individual’s consciousness of the cosmic perspective” — which was greater than he may say a decade later about Star Wars.

Associated content material:

The Letter Between Stanley Kubrick & Arthur C. Clarke That Sparked the Biggest Sci-Fi Movie Ever Made (1964)

What’s the Distinction Between Stanley Kubrick’s & Arthur C. Clarke’s 2001: A Area Odyssey (A Aspect-by-Aspect Comparability)

Stanley Kubrick Explains the Mysterious Ending of 2001: A Area Odyssey in a Newly Unearthed Interview

Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking & Arthur C. Clarke Focus on God, the Universe, and Every part Else

An Animated Carl Sagan Talks with Studs Terkel About Discovering Extraterrestrial Life (1985)

Carl Sagan Tells Johnny Carson What’s Flawed with Star Wars: “They’re All White” & There’s a “Massive Quantity of Human Chauvinism in It” (1978)

Based mostly in Seoul, Colin Marshall writes and broadcasts on cities, language, and tradition. His initiatives embrace the Substack e-newsletter Books on Cities, the ebook The Stateless Metropolis: a Stroll via Twenty first-Century Los Angeles and the video collection The Metropolis in Cinema. Observe him on Twitter at @colinmarshall, on Fb, or on Instagram.


Leave a Reply